Share on Facebook
Share on X
Share on LinkedIn
By Stephen Schahrer
Attorney

With its many seasonal residents, it is unfortunately common for property owners here in the Sunshine State to find someone living in their Florida vacation home.  But what to do when that happens? Fortunately, Florida law offers some solutions to removing the squatter by either an Unlawful Detainer Action (Fla. Stat. 82) or an Ejectment Action (Fla. Stat. 66).  Both of these actions are distinctly different than an Eviction Action (Fla. Stat. 83) because both actions specifically apply against a person or persons who are enjoying the use of a property and are not subject to a lease and who do not pay rent or contribute to the property upkeep and expenses.  Eviction Actions apply where a landlord-tenant relationship exists, commonly through a lease agreement. 

Determining the correct cause of action to give a squatter the boot can be very tedious and confusing.  If the property owner gets it wrong, the case will likely get dismissed.  Additionally, there may be other adverse consequences such as additional costs to refile and a claim bar if the time allotted in the statute of limitations has expired. 

Overall, there are three primary distinctions between an Unlawful Detainer Action and an Ejectment Action.  First, the Defendant in an Ejectment Action is claiming some right, no matter how frivolous, to the property.  In an Unlawful Detainer Action there is no claim of right to the property by the Defendant.

Second, Ejectment Actions are subject to the exclusive original jurisdiction of Florida’s circuit courts.  In contrast, Unlawful Detainer Actions generally fall under subject-matter jurisdiction of Florida’s county courts. The latter includes being subject to the county court’s amount-in-controversy limits.

Additionally, an Unlawful Detainer Action, like an Eviction Action, is afforded the benefits of summary procedure.  That is to say that it is an expedited process to get rid of a squatter.  However, an action for Ejectment does not receive the benefit of the summary procedure process.  This is mainly due to the inherent complexities in determining title and rights to the property.  Therefore, an Ejectment Action is usually more costly than and time consuming than an Unlawful Detainer or an Eviction Action.

This may seem straight forward and there is certainly an abundance of information and forms online.  But the difference between these different causes of action may be very slight and can turn on a single fact or a multitude of variables.  Therefore, it is advisable to seek the advice of qualified legal counsel.

If you are having issues with unwanted people on your property, Boatman Ricci is here to advise and assist you.  The attorneys at Boatman Ricci can help you protect your rights and property. Contact us today to schedule an initial consultation at (239) 330-1494 or info@boatmanricci.com.

* * * * * * * * * *

THIS BLOG IS INTENDED FOR GENERAL INFORMATION PURPOSES ONLY. IT DOES NOT CONSTITUTE LEGAL ADVICE. THE READER SHOULD CONSULT WITH KNOWLEDGEABLE LEGAL COUNSEL TO DETERMINE HOW APPLICABLE LAWS APPLY TO SPECIFIC FACTS AND SITUATIONS. BLOG POSTS ARE BASED ON THE MOST CURRENT INFORMATION AT THE TIME THEY ARE WRITTEN. SINCE IT IS POSSIBLE THAT THE LAWS OR OTHER CIRCUMSTANCES MAY HAVE CHANGED SINCE PUBLICATION, PLEASE CALL US TO DISCUSS ANY ACTION YOU MAY BE CONSIDERING AS A RESULT OF READING THIS BLOG.

#BoatmanRicci #Coronavirus #COVID19 #Lawyers #Litigation 

About the Author
Mr. Schahrer has a diverse professional background including experience working for the Florida State Legislature, the United States Marshals Service headquarters in Washington D.C., and the local non-profit, St. Matthew’s House. He joined Boatman Ricci as a Law Clerk in 2016 and worked with the Firm throughout his time in Law School and then joined the Firm as an Associate Attorney. In his spare time, Mr. Schahrer enjoys training and teaching Martial Arts and spending time with his family in beautiful Naples, FL.