Share on Facebook
Share on X
Share on LinkedIn

Commercial real estate transactions in Florida can be complex, involving significant financial investments, multiple parties, and detailed contracts. Disputes can arise over leases, property sales, construction defects, or zoning issues, and these conflicts can quickly escalate if not handled carefully. At Boatman Ricci, we help businesses and property owners in Naples navigate commercial real estate disputes, providing practical legal strategies to protect their investments and resolve conflicts efficiently.

Common Types of Commercial Real Estate Disputes

Commercial real estate disputes can take many forms, including:

  • Lease Disputes: Conflicts between landlords and tenants over rent, maintenance responsibilities, lease terms, or early termination clauses.
  • Property Sales and Purchase Issues: Breaches of purchase agreements, failure to disclose defects, or disagreements over closing terms.
  • Construction and Development Disputes: Claims involving delays, cost overruns, or defective construction in commercial properties.
  • Boundary and Easement Disputes: Conflicts over property lines, access rights, and shared infrastructure.
  • Zoning and Land Use Conflicts: Issues arising from municipal regulations, permitting, or land use changes that impact property value or use.

Identifying the source of the dispute early is critical for determining the most effective legal strategy.

Legal Strategies for Resolving Commercial Real Estate Disputes

When facing a commercial real estate conflict in Florida, there are several approaches to consider:

Review the Contract Carefully

Many disputes can be traced back to ambiguities or breaches in contracts. Reviewing leases, purchase agreements, or development contracts helps identify potential claims and defenses.

Attempt Negotiation and Mediation

Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) methods such as negotiation or mediation can often resolve disputes more quickly and cost-effectively than litigation. Mediation involves a neutral third party facilitating a mutually acceptable resolution.

Pursue Litigation When Necessary

If negotiation fails, filing a lawsuit may be the best course of action. Florida courts handle commercial real estate disputes involving breach of contract, misrepresentation, or property claims. An attorney experienced in commercial litigation can guide the process and represent your interests in court.

Consider Arbitration Clauses

Some commercial contracts include arbitration clauses, requiring disputes to be resolved outside of court. Understanding the scope of these clauses and preparing a strong case for arbitration is crucial to protect your rights.

Protect Evidence Early

Documenting communications, contracts, invoices, and property conditions is essential. Preserving evidence can strengthen your case and provide leverage during settlement or litigation.

How Florida Law Impacts Commercial Real Estate Disputes

Florida law provides specific protections and procedures for commercial property owners and tenants:

  • Statutes of Limitations: Different types of claims have specific filing deadlines, which must be followed to preserve legal rights.
  • Landlord-Tenant Laws: Commercial leases are generally governed by contract terms; however, Florida statutes provide specific default rules regarding notice, eviction, and remedies.
  • Property Law: Florida law addresses easements, boundary disputes, and property encroachments, which can be critical in resolving disputes over land use or access.

Understanding the applicable statutes and case law is essential for a successful outcome.

How Boatman Ricci Can Help

At Boatman Ricci, we represent businesses, landlords, tenants, and property owners in Naples and throughout Southwest Florida in a wide range of commercial real estate disputes. Our attorneys can:

  • Review and interpret contracts to identify potential risks and claims
  • Negotiate settlements or mediate disputes before litigation
  • Represent clients in complex commercial litigation or arbitration
  • Advise on zoning, permitting, and regulatory compliance issues
  • Protect and preserve evidence to strengthen your case

With our experience and strategic approach, we aim to achieve favorable outcomes while minimizing the disruption to your business operations.

Navigate Real Estate Disputes with Confidence

Commercial real estate disputes in Florida can be financially and operationally challenging. Whether you are dealing with lease disagreements, construction disputes, or property sales conflicts, having an experienced attorney is essential to protect your rights and investments.

If you are facing a commercial real estate dispute in Naples or Southwest Florida, contact Boatman Ricci today. Our team can evaluate your situation, provide strategic guidance, and help you navigate the legal process effectively.

About the Author

Stephen C. Schahrer, a Naples, Florida native, earned his Juris Doctor from Liberty University School of Law after obtaining a Bachelor of Arts in Political Science and a Master of Public Administration from Florida Gulf Coast University. As an AV-Preeminent Rated attorney with a Board Certification in Business Litigation, he practices commercial and business litigation at Boatman Ricci, representing clients in business, construction, real estate, contract, and trust litigation. With prior experience at the Florida State Legislature, the U.S. Marshals Service, and local nonprofits like St. Matthew’s House and Better Together, Stephen leverages his diverse background to provide practical legal solutions, guided by his strong Christian faith and commitment to client relationships. Outside of work, he enjoys spending time with his wife, Rhya, and their three children, practicing martial arts.